In another case of fatal domestic violence, John Tyrie killed his common-law wife, Mary Emery, on July 12, 1910. She was beaten to death with a baseball bat in their home at 276 Kirkpatrick St., Hill District. Tyrie is reported to have beaten her frequently.
The evening of the murder, Tyrie, who worked as a stone mason, came home from work and demanded dinner. He then went out drinking, returning home around midnight. Upset that Tyrie was out drinking and carousing, Emery’s questioning when he returned home led to a quarrel that quickly escalated into the fatal incident.
Emery’s sister, Louise Hairston, was living with them at the time. She heard the entire incident, as did Emery’s children. Tyrie was arrested as he tried to flee the scene.
With Hairston’s eyewitness testimony and Tyrie’s own admission to having struck Emery with a bat, Tyrie’s trial was brief and his first-degree murder conviction, on November 11, 1910, straightforward.
His motion for a new trial was rejected on December 13, 1910. Lacking the resources to pursue an appeal and his clemency request rejected on May 17, 1911, Tyrie was executed on May 23, 1911.
He was the last Allegheny County inmate to be hanged and the last to be executed in the Allegheny County Jail.